Skip to content
DentistsRanked

Best Tooth Extraction Dentists in West Islip, NY (2026)

24 clinics offering tooth extractions, rankedUpdated 0 paid placementsHow we rank →

The short answer

  1. 1

    Best overall for tooth extractions: Vitagliano Orthodontics, ranked #1 of 24 by service score; ranked on access and profile data; Google ratings not yet collected.

Rankings can't be bought. Booking through us earns you a $60 gift card and doesn’t affect order. How we rank

24 West Islip clinics list tooth extractions and are ranked here by service score. 6 open Saturdays and 6 open after 6pm. None list an oral surgeon on staff in our data yet. Google ratings are not yet collected for these clinics.

Top 10 extraction dentists in West Islip at a glance

Top 10 extraction dentists in West Islip at a glance
RankClinicService score
1Vitagliano Orthodontics73
2American Orthodontic Associates67
3Brian Steiger PC67
4Dr. Inayat Mamoor, DDS67
5Dr. Joseph Vitagliano67
6Dr. Marc Bennet67
7Dr. Matthew Tangredi67
8Dr. Pasquale Vitagliano67
9Dr. Sabrina Cheng67
10Dr. Salvatore Ruggiero67

The 24 best extraction dentists in West Islip, ranked

Ordered by service score: the DR Score plus bonuses for a specialist on staff, reviews that mention the service and same-day care where it applies.

  1. Ranked #1 for extraction in West Islip

    #1 Vitagliano Orthodontics

    150 Higbie Ln, West Islip, NY 11795

    73/10015% of factors measured

    Ranked #1 for tooth extractions in West Islip on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.

    Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Vitagliano OrthodonticsFull profile(631) 661-3025
    In their words

    Vitagliano Orthodontics is the leading Orthodontist in West Islip, NY & the surrounding areas. We proudly offer Braces & Invisalign in West Islip, NY! Get in touch with us if you are in need of "Clear Aligners near me". At Vitagliano Orthodontics, we create lifetimes of unlimited smiles for children, teens, and adults! Vitagliano Orthodontics is a family-friendly orthodontic office, where our patients love us and their parents trust us!

    From Vitagliano Orthodontics's own description. Not part of the ranking.

  15. #15 Optum Urgent Care - West Islip

    148 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795

    63/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #15 for tooth extractions in West Islip: evening hours and Saturday and Sunday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Sun 7 AM–10 PM

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Optum Urgent Care - West IslipFull profile(631) 620-3580
    In their words

    ProHEALTH Urgent Care's mission is to get you back to good health and avoid a hospital visit. Serving adults and pediatrics, our wide integrated health system provides a network of specialists if should you require follow up care. Unlike many other facilities, a board-certified doctor is present here to ensure the highest quality care for you. Our highly trained and friendly staff's priority is to make sure your visit is comfortable and quick. We pride ourselves on…

    From Optum Urgent Care - West Islip's own description. Not part of the ranking.

  16. #16 Brian McCurdy DMD

    501 Pease Ln #3420, West Islip, NY 11795

    63/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #16 for tooth extractions in West Islip: evening hours and Saturday and Sunday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon 8 AM–5:30 PM · Tue 9:30 AM–8 PM · Wed 8 AM–5 PM · Thu 8:30 AM–5:30 PM · Fri 8 AM–3 PM · Sat 8:30 PM–12 AM · Sun 12 AM–1 PM

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Brian McCurdy DMDFull profile(631) 653-1228

  17. #17 Bangs Raymond DDS

    144 Higbie Ln, West Islip, NY 11795

    57/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #17 for tooth extractions in West Islip: evening hours and Saturday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon 9 AM–5:30 PM · Tue 9 AM–6:30 PM · Wed closed · Thu 9 AM–5:30 PM · Fri 9 AM–2 PM · Sat 8 AM–1 PM · Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Bangs Raymond DDSFull profile(631) 661-9310

  18. #18 Carla H. Schlissel, DDS

    500 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795

    57/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #18 for tooth extractions in West Islip: evening hours and Saturday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon closed · Tue 10 AM–2 PM · Wed 10 AM–8 PM · Thu closed · Fri 10 AM–6 PM · Sat 10 AM–3 PM · Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Carla H. Schlissel, DDSFull profile(631) 983-3730
    In their words

    At Carla H. Schlissel, DDS dentist office in West Islip NY, your smile is our top priority. Dr. Schlissel with the entire team is dedicated to providing you with the personalized, gentle care that you deserve. Part of our commitment to serving our patients includes providing information that helps them to make more informed decisions about their oral health needs.

    From Carla H. Schlissel, DDS's own description. Not part of the ranking.

  19. #19 Dental365

    440 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, United States

    53/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #19 for tooth extractions in West Islip: evening hours and Saturday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Tue 10 AM–6 PM · Wed 9 AM–7 PM · Thu 9 AM–8 PM · Fri 9 AM–5 PM · Sat 9 AM–3 PM · Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Dental365Full profile(631) 422-4000

  20. #20 Anthony C Fragola DDS

    631 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, United States

    47/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #20 for tooth extractions in West Islip: Saturday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon 9 AM–5 PM · Tue 9 AM–6 PM · Wed closed · Thu–Fri 9 AM–5 PM · Sat 9 AM–12:30 PM · Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Anthony C Fragola DDSFull profile(631) 422-6312

  21. #21 Comfort Dental

    456 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY 11795, United States

    43/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #21 for tooth extractions in West Islip: evening hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon 10 AM–8 PM · Tue 10 AM–7 PM · Wed 9:30 AM–5 PM · Thu 9:30 AM–7 PM · Fri–Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Comfort DentalFull profile(631) 422-1104

  22. #22 New York Center for Orthognathic and Maxillofacial Surgery

    474 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795

    37/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #22 for tooth extractions in West Islip on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Fri 9 AM–5 PM · Sat–Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at New York Center for Orthognathic and Maxillofacial SurgeryFull profile(631) 376-1560
    In their words

    Founded in 1988, New York Center for Orthognathic and Maxillofacial Surgery, NYCOMS is comprised of five board certified oral surgeons, each with an area of expertise, to provide a wide range of specialized services with locations in NYC, Lake Success and West Islip, NY. We are dedicated to using our skill and experience to provide a superior and diversified level of care to our dental patients. We perform procedures ranging from relatively common to more advanced…

    From New York Center for Orthognathic and Maxillofacial Surgery's own description. Not part of the ranking.

  23. #23 Calderón Institute

    720 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795

    37/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #23 for tooth extractions in West Islip on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon 9 AM–5 PM · Tue–Wed 9 AM–4 PM · Thu 10 AM–4 PM · Fri 9:30 AM–1 PM · Sat–Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Calderón InstituteFull profile(631) 328-5050

  24. #24 Rosenthal Peter DDS

    1254 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795

    33/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #24 for tooth extractions in West Islip on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Tue 10 AM–6 PM · Wed closed · Thu 10 AM–6 PM · Fri 9:30 AM–5 PM · Sat–Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Rosenthal Peter DDSFull profile(631) 669-9194

Find the right dentist in West Islip

Answer 2 quick questions and we'll help you find a dentist that fits your needs, location and availability.

West Islip, NY

Book through DentistsRanked and get a $60 Amazon gift card. Terms

Step 1 of 2

What service are you looking for?

  • 100% free for patients
  • No commitment

Emergency and weekend dentists in West Islip

Clinics that list same-day or emergency care, or post Saturday, Sunday or after-6 PM hours. Severe swelling or bleeding: go to a hospital.

What is a tooth extraction?

A tooth extraction removes a tooth that is badly damaged, infected, crowded or loose. A simple extraction removes a visible tooth with instruments. A surgical extraction may involve a small incision or removing bone to reach a broken or impacted tooth.

Tooth extraction: specialist or general dentist?

General dentists do most simple extractions and many surgical ones. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons handle complex cases, such as deeply impacted teeth, teeth close to nerves, or patients who need IV sedation or general anesthesia.

None of West Islip's 24 clinics offering tooth extractions list an oral surgeon on staff in our data yet. See oral surgeons in West Islip

How much does a tooth extraction cost in West Islip?

Typical ranges in USD for West Islip, NY. Your price depends on the tooth, the case and the clinic.

How much does a tooth extraction cost in West Islip?
TypeTypical range (USD)BasisAs of
Simple extraction, per tooth$120–$410DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for New York—
Surgical extraction, per tooth$250–$980DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for New York—

Estimates, not quotes. Ask the clinic for a written estimate. Full tooth extraction cost guide for West Islip

What to expect from a tooth extraction

Typical ranges for most patients. Your dentist's plan may differ.

A tooth extraction: visits, chair time and recovery
FactTypically
Typical visitsUsually 1 visit, plus a follow-up if needed
Chair timeAbout 20–40 minutes for a simple extraction; longer for surgical ones
RecoveryMost people feel better within 3–7 days; full gum healing takes a few weeks
When to see a specialistImpacted or broken teeth, teeth near the sinus or nerves, medical conditions that complicate surgery, or when sedation is needed

How we ranked West Islip extraction dentists

We scored 24 West Islip clinics offering tooth extractions on 6 factors: reputation 45%, review volume 15%, recency 10%, access 15%, services 10%, profile completeness 5%. 2 were excluded (2 duplicate listings). Google ratings are not yet collected, so each score is renormalised over the factors we measured. Data from Google listings and clinic websites, refreshed October 21, 2026.

Paid placement never changes a rank or score. Featured clinics are paid, labelled, limited to 3 and shown above the ranking, outside it.

Read the full method: formula, sources and exclusions

DR Score factors and weights
FactorWeightComputed fromIn West Islip data
Reputation45%Bayesian-adjusted Google star ratingNot yet collected
Review volume15%log10(review count) against the city maximumNot yet collected
Recency10%Share of reviews in the last 12 monthsNot yet collected
Access15%Evenings, Saturday, Sunday, same-day/emergency, accepting new patientsMeasured
Services10%Services offered out of 17Measured
Profile completeness5%Named dentists, years open, languages, insurance, photosMeasured

Tooth extractions in West Islip: frequently asked questions

Who is the best tooth extraction dentist in West Islip?

Vitagliano Orthodontics ranks #1 of 24 West Islip clinics offering tooth extractions by DentistsRanked service score. American Orthodontic Associates ranks #2. The score weighs reputation, access, services and profile data, plus a bonus for an oral surgeon on staff.

How much does a tooth extraction cost in West Islip, NY?

A tooth extraction in West Islip typically costs $290–$1,015 USD. By type: simple extraction, per tooth $120–$410; surgical extraction, per tooth $250–$980. These are estimates, not quotes. Basis: DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for New York. Ask the clinic for a written estimate.

Do general dentists in West Islip do tooth extractions?

Yes. None of the 24 West Islip clinics offering tooth extractions list an oral surgeon on staff in our data, so general dentists there typically provide it. Typical reasons to see an oral surgeon: impacted or broken teeth, teeth near the sinus or nerves, medical conditions that complicate surgery, or when sedation is needed.

Is a tooth extraction covered by insurance or Medicaid in New York?

Many dental insurance plans cover extractions as basic care, often at 70–80% after the deductible. Surgical extractions may be billed at a different rate. Medicaid commonly covers medically necessary extractions; adult benefits vary by state.

Does a tooth extraction hurt?

The area is numbed with local anesthetic, so most patients feel pressure rather than sharp pain during an extraction. Soreness and swelling for a few days afterward are common. Your dentist will give aftercare instructions, and pain that gets worse after day three should be checked.

Which West Islip tooth extraction dentists are open on Saturday?

6 of 24 West Islip clinics offering tooth extractions list Saturday hours, including Optum Urgent Care - West Islip, Brian McCurdy DMD and Bangs Raymond DDS. Hours come from each clinic's listing; check with the clinic before you go, since holiday and summer hours can change.

How many dentists offer tooth extractions in West Islip?

24 West Islip clinics list tooth extractions in our data. 0 of them list an oral surgeon on staff. 6 are open Saturdays. Google ratings are on file for none of them. Counts update when clinics change their profiles.

Update log for West Islip

  1. : DR Scores recalculated for 25 clinics.
  2. : 2 duplicate listings merged.

Related pages