Skip to content
DentistsRanked

Best Tooth Extraction Dentists in Shirley, NY (2026)

15 clinics offering tooth extractions, rankedUpdated 0 paid placementsHow we rank →

The short answer

  1. 1

    Best overall for tooth extractions: Dr. Carl P. Palmblad, DDS, ranked #1 of 15 by service score; ranked on access and profile data; Google ratings not yet collected.

Rankings can't be bought. Booking through us earns you a $60 gift card and doesn’t affect order. How we rank

15 Shirley clinics list tooth extractions and are ranked here by service score. 4 open Saturdays and 3 open after 6pm. None list an oral surgeon on staff in our data yet. Google ratings are not yet collected for these clinics.

Top 10 extraction dentists in Shirley at a glance

Top 10 extraction dentists in Shirley at a glance
RankClinicService score
1Dr. Carl P. Palmblad, DDS73
2Island East Dental Group73
3Dr. William Peppiatt, DDS67
4Klein Gary M DDS67
5Mark Rienecker67
6Mohammed Bhuian DDS67
7Schwartz Steven DDS67
8Sweet Sleep Associates67
9Zelenka Joanne67
10CityMD Shirley Urgent Care - Long Island63

The 15 best extraction dentists in Shirley, ranked

Ordered by service score: the DR Score plus bonuses for a specialist on staff, reviews that mention the service and same-day care where it applies.

  10. #10 CityMD Shirley Urgent Care - Long Island

    895 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

    63/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #10 for tooth extractions in Shirley: evening hours and Saturday and Sunday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Fri 9 AM–9 PM · Sat–Sun 9 AM–5 PM

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at CityMD Shirley Urgent Care - Long IslandFull profile(631) 230-5770

  11. #11 Fluger Stephen D DDS

    691A Montauk Hwy A, Shirley, NY 11967

    53/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #11 for tooth extractions in Shirley: evening hours and Saturday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon 9 AM–1 PM · Tue 9 AM–7 PM · Wed 9 AM–1 PM · Thu 9 AM–5 PM · Fri closed · Sat 9 AM–2 PM · Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Fluger Stephen D DDSFull profile(631) 399-4470

  12. #12 MD365 - Shirley

    800 Montauk Hwy Ste 8, Shirley, NY 11967

    47/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #12 for tooth extractions in Shirley: Saturday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Fri 8 AM–6 PM · Sat 8 AM–4 PM · Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at MD365 - ShirleyFull profile(631) 772-4646
    In their words

    At MD365, we truly understand the needs of the community. Why? Because we are a part of the community. Our board- certified doctors, and health care team, work and live right here in the area. At MD365 your out of pocket costs are lower for Primary and Urgent care services saving you $$. You get continuity of care by being able to see your own Providers for Urgent Care as well as Routine Care. We offer full line of vaccinations from birth, school years, adult, including…

    From MD365 - Shirley's own description. Not part of the ranking.

  13. #13 Shirley Orthodontics and Pediatric Dentistry

    640 Montauk Hwy C, Shirley, NY 11967

    47/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #13 for tooth extractions in Shirley: Saturday hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Tue 9 AM–6 PM · Wed 1 PM–5 PM · Thu closed · Fri 8 AM–5 PM · Sat 8 AM–12 PM · Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Shirley Orthodontics and Pediatric DentistryFull profile(631) 399-1600
    In their words

    Welcome to Shirley Orthodontics and Pediatric Dentistry! Voted best orthodontists on Long Island by Pulse Magazine, our practice has been treating patients in Shirley for over 40 years! Dr. Patrick Sabo, Dr. Mark Rienecker, and Dr. Erin Diamantakis are creating beautiful smiles for children and adults using braces and invisalign. We have expanded our practice and built a pediatric office right next door. Dr. Shawn Francis II is a wonderful new addition to our dental family!

    From Shirley Orthodontics and Pediatric Dentistry's own description. Not part of the ranking.

  14. #14 Affordable Dental Care

    1463 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley, NY 11967, United States

    47/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #14 for tooth extractions in Shirley: evening hours.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Tue closed · Wed 9 AM–6:30 PM · Thu–Fri 9:30 AM–6:30 PM · Sat–Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Affordable Dental CareFull profile(631) 504-6434
    In their words

    Our Affordable Dental Care Clinic in Shirley, NY now ready to provides a wide variety of dental care services and procedures to address all of our patients' dental health needs. Contact Shirley Dental Care for Dental Crowns, Dental Implants, Exams and Cleanings, Cosmetic Dentistry, Restorative Dentistry Overview, etc...

    From Affordable Dental Care's own description. Not part of the ranking.

  15. #15 Clinica shirley

    550 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

    33/10030% of factors measured

    Ranked #15 for tooth extractions in Shirley on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.

    Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.

    Hours
    Mon–Tue 9 AM–5 PM · Wed closed · Thu 9 AM–5 PM · Fri–Sun closed

    General dentistryCleaningEmergency careRoot canalExtractionWisdom teethImplantsInvisalign+9 more

    Book appointment at Clinica shirleyFull profile(347) 336-5603

Find the right dentist in Shirley

Answer 2 quick questions and we'll help you find a dentist that fits your needs, location and availability.

Shirley, NY

Book through DentistsRanked and get a $60 Amazon gift card. Terms

Step 1 of 2

What service are you looking for?

  • 100% free for patients
  • No commitment

Emergency and weekend dentists in Shirley

Clinics that list same-day or emergency care, or post Saturday, Sunday or after-6 PM hours. Severe swelling or bleeding: go to a hospital.

What is a tooth extraction?

A tooth extraction removes a tooth that is badly damaged, infected, crowded or loose. A simple extraction removes a visible tooth with instruments. A surgical extraction may involve a small incision or removing bone to reach a broken or impacted tooth.

Tooth extraction: specialist or general dentist?

General dentists do most simple extractions and many surgical ones. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons handle complex cases, such as deeply impacted teeth, teeth close to nerves, or patients who need IV sedation or general anesthesia.

None of Shirley's 15 clinics offering tooth extractions list an oral surgeon on staff in our data yet. See oral surgeons in Shirley

How much does a tooth extraction cost in Shirley?

Typical ranges in USD for Shirley, NY. Your price depends on the tooth, the case and the clinic.

How much does a tooth extraction cost in Shirley?
TypeTypical range (USD)BasisAs of
Simple extraction, per tooth$120–$410DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for New York—
Surgical extraction, per tooth$250–$980DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for New York—

Estimates, not quotes. Ask the clinic for a written estimate. Full tooth extraction cost guide for Shirley

What to expect from a tooth extraction

Typical ranges for most patients. Your dentist's plan may differ.

A tooth extraction: visits, chair time and recovery
FactTypically
Typical visitsUsually 1 visit, plus a follow-up if needed
Chair timeAbout 20–40 minutes for a simple extraction; longer for surgical ones
RecoveryMost people feel better within 3–7 days; full gum healing takes a few weeks
When to see a specialistImpacted or broken teeth, teeth near the sinus or nerves, medical conditions that complicate surgery, or when sedation is needed

How we ranked Shirley extraction dentists

We scored 15 Shirley clinics offering tooth extractions on 6 factors: reputation 45%, review volume 15%, recency 10%, access 15%, services 10%, profile completeness 5%. 14 were excluded (14 duplicate listings). Google ratings are not yet collected, so each score is renormalised over the factors we measured. Data from Google listings and clinic websites, refreshed October 21, 2026.

Paid placement never changes a rank or score. Featured clinics are paid, labelled, limited to 3 and shown above the ranking, outside it.

Read the full method: formula, sources and exclusions

DR Score factors and weights
FactorWeightComputed fromIn Shirley data
Reputation45%Bayesian-adjusted Google star ratingNot yet collected
Review volume15%log10(review count) against the city maximumNot yet collected
Recency10%Share of reviews in the last 12 monthsNot yet collected
Access15%Evenings, Saturday, Sunday, same-day/emergency, accepting new patientsMeasured
Services10%Services offered out of 17Measured
Profile completeness5%Named dentists, years open, languages, insurance, photosMeasured

Tooth extractions in Shirley: frequently asked questions

Who is the best tooth extraction dentist in Shirley?

Dr. Carl P. Palmblad, DDS ranks #1 of 15 Shirley clinics offering tooth extractions by DentistsRanked service score. Island East Dental Group ranks #2. The score weighs reputation, access, services and profile data, plus a bonus for an oral surgeon on staff.

How much does a tooth extraction cost in Shirley, NY?

A tooth extraction in Shirley typically costs $290–$1,015 USD. By type: simple extraction, per tooth $120–$410; surgical extraction, per tooth $250–$980. These are estimates, not quotes. Basis: DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for New York. Ask the clinic for a written estimate.

Do general dentists in Shirley do tooth extractions?

Yes. None of the 15 Shirley clinics offering tooth extractions list an oral surgeon on staff in our data, so general dentists there typically provide it. Typical reasons to see an oral surgeon: impacted or broken teeth, teeth near the sinus or nerves, medical conditions that complicate surgery, or when sedation is needed.

Is a tooth extraction covered by insurance or Medicaid in New York?

Many dental insurance plans cover extractions as basic care, often at 70–80% after the deductible. Surgical extractions may be billed at a different rate. Medicaid commonly covers medically necessary extractions; adult benefits vary by state.

Does a tooth extraction hurt?

The area is numbed with local anesthetic, so most patients feel pressure rather than sharp pain during an extraction. Soreness and swelling for a few days afterward are common. Your dentist will give aftercare instructions, and pain that gets worse after day three should be checked.

Which Shirley tooth extraction dentists are open on Saturday?

4 of 15 Shirley clinics offering tooth extractions list Saturday hours, including CityMD Shirley Urgent Care - Long Island, Fluger Stephen D DDS and MD365 - Shirley. Hours come from each clinic's listing; check with the clinic before you go, since holiday and summer hours can change.

How many dentists offer tooth extractions in Shirley?

15 Shirley clinics list tooth extractions in our data. 0 of them list an oral surgeon on staff. 4 are open Saturdays. Google ratings are on file for none of them. Counts update when clinics change their profiles.

Update log for Shirley

  1. : DR Scores recalculated for 15 clinics.
  2. : 14 duplicate listings merged.

Related pages