Best Tooth Extraction Dentists in Middleton, WI (2026)

23 clinics offering tooth extractions, rankedUpdated October 21, 20260 paid placementsHow we rank →

The short answer

1
Best overall for tooth extractions: Dental Pro Shop, ranked #1 of 23 by service score; ranked on access and profile data; Google ratings not yet collected.

Rankings can't be bought. Booking through us earns you a $60 gift card and doesn’t affect order. How we rank

23 Middleton clinics list tooth extractions and are ranked here by service score. None list an oral surgeon on staff in our data yet. Google ratings are not yet collected for these clinics.

Top 10 extraction dentists in Middleton at a glance

Top 10 extraction dentists in Middleton at a glance
Rank	Clinic	Service score
1	Dental Pro Shop	67
2	Dr. William Graf	67
3	Family Dentistry And Orthodontics Of Middleton	67
4	Greenway Dental Center	67
5	Greg Killian	67
6	Gums Of Steel	67
7	H Q Dental Laboratory	67
8	James A. Lord, DDS	67
9	James Shipley	67
10	Model Jenifer	67

The 23 best extraction dentists in Middleton, ranked

Ordered by service score: the DR Score plus bonuses for a specialist on staff, reviews that mention the service and same-day care where it applies.

Ranked #1 for extraction in Middleton
#1 Dental Pro Shop
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #1 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Dental Pro Shop Full profile
#2 Dr. William Graf
7780 Elmwood Ave #108, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #2 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Dr. William Graf Full profile (608) 836-1020
#3 Family Dentistry And Orthodontics Of Middleton
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #3 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Family Dentistry And Orthodontics Of Middleton Full profile
#4 Greenway Dental Center
8309 Greenway Blvd # 110, Middleton, WI 53562
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #4 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Greenway Dental Center Full profile (608) 824-0824
#5 Greg Killian
6213 Middleton Springs Dr, Middleton, WI 53562
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #5 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Greg Killian Full profile (608) 831-0467
#6 Gums Of Steel
8313 Greenway Blvd, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #6 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Gums Of Steel Full profile (608) 520-3689
#7 H Q Dental Laboratory
2013 Mayflower Dr, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #7 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at H Q Dental Laboratory Full profile (608) 824-0456
#8 James A. Lord, DDS
1001 N Gammon Rd #2, Middleton, WI 53562
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #8 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at James A. Lord, DDS Full profile (608) 831-5151
#9 James Shipley
8383 Greenway Blvd Ste 120, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #9 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at James Shipley Full profile (608) 836-1422
#10 Model Jenifer
6333 University Ave # 110, Middleton, WI 53562
67/10015% of factors measured
Ranked #10 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Model Jenifer Full profile (608) 238-6244
#11 Mercy Dental Group
8215 Greenway Blvd Ste. 100, Middleton, WI 53562
37/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #11 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Mercy Dental Group Full profile (608) 709-7470
#12 Madison Dentistry
6519 University Ave, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
37/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #12 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Thu 7:30 AM–4:30 PM · Fri–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Madison Dentistry Full profile (608) 824-0824
In their words
At Madison Dentistry - Dentist in Middleton, WI, we see our patients as a part of the family - and family is always our top priority. We are all dedicated to you, from our front desk to our dentists and hygienist. Our focus is on excellent patient care. Madison Dentistry is conveniently located at 6519 University Ave Middleton, WI 53562. Contact us today to book your appointment and get your dream smile!
From Madison Dentistry's own description. Not part of the ranking.
#13 Middleton Family Dental
6660 University Ave, Middleton, WI 53562
37/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #13 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Thu 7:30 AM–4:30 PM · Fri–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Middleton Family Dental Full profile (608) 836-1446
In their words
Our team is dedicated to being on your team. We’re always working hard to provide you with the most effective oral healthcare treatments, the latest cosmetic solutions to fit your smile dreams, and the best ways to give you a beautifully healthy smile. We are here to serve you.
From Middleton Family Dental's own description. Not part of the ranking.
#14 Distinctive Dental Implants
8333 Greenway Blvd Suite #190, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
37/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #14 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon closed · Tue–Thu 9 AM–5:30 PM · Fri 9 AM–4 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Distinctive Dental Implants Full profile
#15 Campfire Pediatric Dentistry
8391 Greenway Blvd Suite 100, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
37/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #15 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Tue closed · Wed–Fri 8 AM–5 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Campfire Pediatric Dentistry Full profile (608) 481-8089
In their words
Welcome to Campfire Pediatric Dentistry, where every child in Middleton can enjoy the adventure of smile care with curiosity, wonder, and trust. Dr. Nathan Benassi and our friendly team take a compassionate and educational approach, nurturing a soothing experience and fun-filled memories for the whole family. We’re so excited to partner with you and your little one on the path to thriving dental wellness, so come explore with us today!
From Campfire Pediatric Dentistry's own description. Not part of the ranking.
#16 First Choice Dental
7780 Elmwood Ave #108, Middleton, WI 53562
33/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #16 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Thu 7 AM–5 PM · Fri 7 AM–4 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at First Choice Dental Full profile (608) 836-1020
#17 Capital Endodontics
8333 Greenway Blvd Suite 380, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
33/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #17 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Fri 7:30 AM–4:30 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Capital Endodontics Full profile (608) 442-3300
In their words
Welcome to Capital Endodontics, serving Madison, Wisconsin, and the surrounding communities. We are proud to be the area’s largest and most experienced team of root canal specialists, and we strive every day to provide patients with the highest quality endodontic care.
From Capital Endodontics's own description. Not part of the ranking.
#18 Dr. Chad Campanelli
8333 Greenway Blvd Suite 380, Middleton, WI 53562
33/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #18 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Fri 7:30 AM–4:30 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Dr. Chad Campanelli Full profile (608) 442-3300
#19 Hartjes Dental Associates, Drs. Brad and Joel Hartjes
1001 N Gammon Rd, Middleton, WI 53562
33/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #19 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Thu 7 AM–4 PM · Fri 7 AM–12:30 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Hartjes Dental Associates, Drs. Brad and Joel Hartjes Full profile (608) 836-5600
#20 Hartstone Dental
1001 N Gammon Rd #2, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
33/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #20 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Thu 7 AM–4 PM · Fri 7 AM–12:30 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Hartstone Dental Full profile (608) 836-5600
#21 Midwest Dental
6213 Middleton Springs Dr, Middleton, WI 53562, United States
33/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #21 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Thu 7:30 AM–4:30 PM · Fri 7:30 AM–12 PM · Sat–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Midwest Dental Full profile (608) 831-0467
In their words
At Midwest Dental in Middleton, you can trust you're in the right place. With so many affordable dental services to choose from, we're sure our pediatric and emergency dentists are there for you when you need it most. Provided dental services range from dental treatments like a root canal or dental crown, to routine teeth cleanings and teeth whitening. Our commitment to you lies within our promise to provide a lifetime of quality dental care. Review the full list of offered…
From Midwest Dental's own description. Not part of the ranking.
#22 Distinctive Dentistry- Now Greenway Family Dental
8215 Greenway Blvd, Middleton, WI 53562
33/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #22 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon 8 AM–5 PM · Tue–Thu 8 AM–5:30 PM · Fri–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Distinctive Dentistry- Now Greenway Family Dental Full profile (608) 836-1422
#23 Dr. Paul A Insolera
6405 Century Ave, Middleton, WI 53562
33/10030% of factors measured
Ranked #23 for tooth extractions in Middleton on access and profile data; Google ratings are not yet collected.
Based on access, services and profile completeness; Google ratings not yet collected.
Hours
Mon–Thu 8:30 AM–4:30 PM · Fri–Sun closed
General dentistry Cleaning Emergency care Root canal Extraction Wisdom teeth Implants Invisalign +9 more
Book appointment at Dr. Paul A Insolera Full profile (608) 833-0865

Find the right dentist in Middleton

Answer 2 quick questions and we'll help you find a dentist that fits your needs, location and availability.

Middleton, WI

Book through DentistsRanked and get a $60 Amazon gift card. Terms

Step 1 of 2

What service are you looking for?

100% free for patients
No commitment

What is a tooth extraction?

A tooth extraction removes a tooth that is badly damaged, infected, crowded or loose. A simple extraction removes a visible tooth with instruments. A surgical extraction may involve a small incision or removing bone to reach a broken or impacted tooth.

Tooth extraction: specialist or general dentist?

General dentists do most simple extractions and many surgical ones. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons handle complex cases, such as deeply impacted teeth, teeth close to nerves, or patients who need IV sedation or general anesthesia.

None of Middleton's 23 clinics offering tooth extractions list an oral surgeon on staff in our data yet. See oral surgeons in Middleton

How much does a tooth extraction cost in Middleton?

Typical ranges in USD for Middleton, WI. Your price depends on the tooth, the case and the clinic.

How much does a tooth extraction cost in Middleton?
Type	Typical range (USD)	Basis	As of
Simple extraction, per tooth	$85–$280	DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for Wisconsin	—
Surgical extraction, per tooth	$170–$680	DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for Wisconsin	—

Estimates, not quotes. Ask the clinic for a written estimate. Full tooth extraction cost guide for Middleton

What to expect from a tooth extraction

Typical ranges for most patients. Your dentist's plan may differ.

A tooth extraction: visits, chair time and recovery
Fact	Typically
Typical visits	Usually 1 visit, plus a follow-up if needed
Chair time	About 20–40 minutes for a simple extraction; longer for surgical ones
Recovery	Most people feel better within 3–7 days; full gum healing takes a few weeks
When to see a specialist	Impacted or broken teeth, teeth near the sinus or nerves, medical conditions that complicate surgery, or when sedation is needed

How we ranked Middleton extraction dentists

We scored 23 Middleton clinics offering tooth extractions on 6 factors: reputation 45%, review volume 15%, recency 10%, access 15%, services 10%, profile completeness 5%. 1 was excluded (1 duplicate listing). Google ratings are not yet collected, so each score is renormalised over the factors we measured. Data from Google listings and clinic websites, refreshed October 21, 2026.

Paid placement never changes a rank or score. Featured clinics are paid, labelled, limited to 3 and shown above the ranking, outside it.

Read the full method: formula, sources and exclusions

DR Score factors and weights
Factor	Weight	Computed from	In Middleton data
Reputation	45%	Bayesian-adjusted Google star rating	Not yet collected
Review volume	15%	log10(review count) against the city maximum	Not yet collected
Recency	10%	Share of reviews in the last 12 months	Not yet collected
Access	15%	Evenings, Saturday, Sunday, same-day/emergency, accepting new patients	Measured
Services	10%	Services offered out of 17	Measured
Profile completeness	5%	Named dentists, years open, languages, insurance, photos	Measured

Tooth extractions in Middleton: frequently asked questions

Who is the best tooth extraction dentist in Middleton?

Dental Pro Shop ranks #1 of 23 Middleton clinics offering tooth extractions by DentistsRanked service score. Dr. William Graf ranks #2. The score weighs reputation, access, services and profile data, plus a bonus for an oral surgeon on staff.

How much does a tooth extraction cost in Middleton, WI?

A tooth extraction in Middleton typically costs $200–$700 USD. By type: simple extraction, per tooth $85–$280; surgical extraction, per tooth $170–$680. These are estimates, not quotes. Basis: DentistsRanked estimate from typical fees, adjusted for Wisconsin. Ask the clinic for a written estimate.

Do general dentists in Middleton do tooth extractions?

Yes. None of the 23 Middleton clinics offering tooth extractions list an oral surgeon on staff in our data, so general dentists there typically provide it. Typical reasons to see an oral surgeon: impacted or broken teeth, teeth near the sinus or nerves, medical conditions that complicate surgery, or when sedation is needed.

Is a tooth extraction covered by insurance or Medicaid in Wisconsin?

Many dental insurance plans cover extractions as basic care, often at 70–80% after the deductible. Surgical extractions may be billed at a different rate. Medicaid commonly covers medically necessary extractions; adult benefits vary by state.

Does a tooth extraction hurt?

The area is numbed with local anesthetic, so most patients feel pressure rather than sharp pain during an extraction. Soreness and swelling for a few days afterward are common. Your dentist will give aftercare instructions, and pain that gets worse after day three should be checked.

How many dentists offer tooth extractions in Middleton?

23 Middleton clinics list tooth extractions in our data. 0 of them list an oral surgeon on staff. Google ratings are on file for none of them. Counts update when clinics change their profiles.

Top 10 extraction dentists in Middleton at a glance

The 23 best extraction dentists in Middleton, ranked

#1 Dental Pro Shop

#2 Dr. William Graf

#3 Family Dentistry And Orthodontics Of Middleton

#4 Greenway Dental Center

#5 Greg Killian

#6 Gums Of Steel

#7 H Q Dental Laboratory

#8 James A. Lord, DDS

#9 James Shipley

#10 Model Jenifer

#11 Mercy Dental Group

#12 Madison Dentistry

#13 Middleton Family Dental

#14 Distinctive Dental Implants

#15 Campfire Pediatric Dentistry

#16 First Choice Dental

#17 Capital Endodontics

#18 Dr. Chad Campanelli

#19 Hartjes Dental Associates, Drs. Brad and Joel Hartjes

#20 Hartstone Dental

#21 Midwest Dental

#22 Distinctive Dentistry- Now Greenway Family Dental

#23 Dr. Paul A Insolera